Holiday scams: How to shop safely as AI makes fraud harder to spot
The holiday season can create particularly favourable conditions for scammers. With consumers shopping online, looking for deals and expecting deliveries, familiar fraud tactics can become much more convincing.
Andy Davis , Global Research Director, NCC Group, explains what consumers should watch for, how AI is changing scams and the steps people can take to protect themselves. Key takeaways - The holiday season gives scammers more opportunities to make familiar fraud tactics believable. - AI can make phishing and impersonation more convincing, making some traditional warning signs less reliable. - Consumers should slow down, verify unexpected requests independently and avoid following unsolicited links involving payments or personal information.
Why are scams more convincing during the holidays?
“The holiday season creates particularly favourable conditions for scammers. More people are shopping online, looking for deals and expecting deliveries, often while under pressure to get everything sorted in time. That urgency is exactly what cybercriminals look to exploit.
“Scammers want people to act before they think. A limited-time offer, an unexpected delivery notification or an urgent payment request can all create enough pressure for someone to click a link or hand over details they ordinarily wouldn’t. Rather than saying every type of scam necessarily increases, I’d say the festive period creates more opportunities for familiar scams to succeed.”
Where should consumers watch for scams?
“Scammers will go wherever consumers are. That means email and text messages, but also social media, online adverts, marketplaces, fake retail websites and phone calls.
“Phishing emails and texts impersonating retailers or delivery companies can be particularly effective at this time of year because people may genuinely be waiting for several parcels. Social media is another area to watch. Fraudulent adverts and convincing fake stores can appear alongside legitimate content, making it increasingly important to check who you are actually buying from before entering any personal or payment information.”
What scams should consumers watch for?
“One I’d be particularly alert to is impersonation of a well-known retailer or delivery company. You might receive a realistic-looking message saying a parcel couldn’t be delivered or that a small additional payment is needed. The link takes you to a site designed to look like the real company, but its purpose is to capture your payment details or login credentials.
“Fake charity appeals are another one to watch over the holidays. Scammers can exploit people’s generosity with emotional and urgent requests for donations, so consumers should always verify the organisation independently rather than donating through an unsolicited link.”
How is AI making scams harder to recognise?
“AI hasn’t fundamentally changed the objective of these scams, but it is giving criminals tools to make them more convincing and easier to scale. Generative AI can help produce more polished phishing messages, while synthetic images, video and audio can make impersonation far more believable.
“That makes some of the traditional warning signs less dependable. Poor spelling or an obviously fake image used to help give a scam away, but consumers can’t assume that will always be the case anymore. With convincing deepfake video and cloned voices, seeing or hearing someone isn’t necessarily proof that the communication is genuine.”
What could an AI-enabled scam look like?
“A good example would be a deepfake advert on social media that appears to show a familiar or trusted person promoting a product or an incredible deal. The video itself may look convincing, but clicking through could take the consumer to a fraudulent website designed to steal their money or personal information.
“Voice cloning is another concern. AI can be used to imitate somebody’s voice and create a convincing urgent request for money or information. If a request is unexpected, particularly where money is involved, consumers should verify it through a separate trusted channel rather than relying on the fact that the person sounds familiar.”
How can consumers protect themselves from holiday scams?
“My biggest piece of advice is simply to slow down. Scammers thrive on urgency, whether that’s an amazing deal that supposedly ends in ten minutes or a message saying you need to make an immediate payment to receive a parcel.”
Five scams consumers should watch out for
AI-enhanced adverts and phishing AI can help criminals create polished adverts, emails, images and voices that appear credible. Professional presentation is no longer proof that a communication is genuine.
Fake online shops Fraudulent websites can imitate genuine retailers and create convincing product listings, policies and checkout pages.
Fraudulent adverts and sellers Scam adverts, listings and sellers can appear on legitimate social platforms and online marketplaces.
Fake account and payment alerts Messages asking shoppers to verify a payment, cancel an order or secure an account may lead to cloned login pages.
Delivery and redelivery scams Fraudsters can exploit the parcels people are expecting with fake tracking links, address requests and small redelivery fees.
About Andy Davis
Andy Davis is Global Research Director at NCC Group. With 30+ years’ experience across UK Government, consultancy and professional services, he leads the Group’s global research programme, setting strategy, ensuring technical excellence and governing research output. Previously Chief Research Officer at IRM and Head of Security Research at KPMG, Andy joined NCC Group in 2010 and later built its global Transport Practice. He is known for turning complex cyber risk into clear, actionable guidance for engineers and boards.











