The chief AI officer (CAIO) has arrived. The authority to actually call the shots? Not so much.
In just a year, the share of companies with CAIOs has reportedly jumped from 26% to 76%, according to new research from IBM’s Institute for Business Value (IBV). Yet only 18% of companies grant those executives full control over AI investment decisions.
In other words, companies have gotten very good at putting someone in charge of AI. Giving that person real authority over AI budgets, strategy and deployment is lagging.
“I often see what I call ‘random acts of AI,’” Caroline Roche, a Managing Partner at IBM Consulting, said in an interview with IBM Think. “These are initiatives optimized for their own corner of the business but disconnected from a shared outcome.”
“Without a central orchestrator, your business ends up with solutions that don’t talk to each other, are fragmented and can’t effectively scale,” said Joanne Wright, IBM’s SVP for Transformation and Operations, in a Q&A with IBM Think.
But appointing an orchestrator is only half the equation. To be effective, Roche said, that person needs the “visibility, capability and authority to align the entire system and guide it toward a shared outcome.”
So what separates a CAIO with a title from one with real clout?
Partnering with Oxford Economics, IBV surveyed over 1,600 executives worldwide and found that eight CAIO behaviors—such as being willing to pause, adjust or redirect AI or redeploying productivity gains—are linked to transformational enterprise-wide AI outcomes. The CAIOs who embrace these behaviors have a much higher impact on the bottom line and specifically deliver AI ROI that is more than double what all other CAIOs achieve.
For example, 96% of high-impact CAIOs say they stop or reduce investment in AI initiatives that fail to deliver, even when those projects have senior sponsorship. Just 46% of other CAIOs said the same.
And high-impact CAIOs don’t simply pocket AI’s productivity gains. Ninety-five percent of top-performing CAIOs say they reinvest those gains into higher-value transformation, compared with 44% of other respondents.
That’s the difference between having a CAIO on the org chart and giving one real clout. If 2025 was about creating the CAIO role, 2026 may be about giving the job some teeth.











